1995-96 Portland Beavers - Jeff Muggleston
1996-97 Hamilton Predators - Matt Beatty
1997-98 Hamilton Predators - Matt Beatty
1998-99 Cleveland Barons - Kevin Schmitz
1999-00 Hamilton Predators - Matt Beatty
2000-01 Washington Whiskeyjacks - Randy Lazzarotto
2001-02 San Antonio Outlaws - Kelly Gardner
2002-03 Houston Comets - Al Godfrey
2003-04 Cleveland Barons - Kevin Schmitz
2004-05 Oakland Oceanus - Joe Sutherland
2005-06 Oakland Oceanus - Joe Sutherland
2006-07 Cleveland Barons - Kevin Schmitz
2007-08 Oakland Oceanus - Joe Sutherland
2008-09 Quebec City Thundercats - Jordan Schartner
2009-10 Milwaukee Ice Dragons - Lee Snowden
2010-11 Mississippi Mudbugs - Jeff Kwok
2011-12 Louisiana Voodoo - Ryan Pollock
2012-13 Green Bay Glory - Brian Dillon
2013-14 Toledo Honey Badgers - Jordan Schartner
2014-15 Oakland Assassins - Joe Sutherland
2015-16 Las Vegas Desperado - Ferrel Hedberg
2016-17 Indianapolis Goats - Scott Snowden
2017-18 Staten Island Killer Bees - Jeff Kwok
2018-19 Staten Island Killer Bees - Jeff Kwok
